Great dissatisfaction is at present felt at the manner in which emigrant ships are supplied with medical men and the coroner of Liverpool gave expression in no very measured terms, at the close of business on Friday week: --

“I wish (he said) to make an observation on the case of the female in the death-house: and really I hardly know how, in any language of mine, to bring it sufficiently under your notice with a desire to have it remedied, if it be possible to have it remedied: for the number of cases that are now occurring, and as it appears to me in some measure arising from the very inefficient medical staff on board emigrant ships, renders it necessary that something should be done. I am compelled, from the facts that come under my notice, to go very rigidly into all cases of death occurring on board emigrant ships. Within the last two or three days, two children, the children of a German emigrant – one, I believe, twelve years of ages, the other some years younger – died in the river on board a ship called the Ben Nevis. I believe there were no less than two medical men on board that vessel. I do not want to say anything of the professional qualifications of those gentlemen, but it was their duty to have a proper and authentic certificate on shore accounting for the death of those children. A certificate, I believe, was sent on shore only on Sunday last, and it was taken, I think, to Major Greig. Major Greig, from the nature of the certificate, considered it was only a case that required parish attention, and gave directions accordingly. One of the medical men certified that the children had died from cholera, whilst the other said that they had not died from cholera, but he did not say what the children died from. I directed an inquiry to me made from the owners of the vessel, and the result was, that a proper certificate was to have been sent to me by ten o’clock on the following morning. In the meantime, Mr. Gray, finding the discrepancy between the two medical certificates, said he would not interfere until the coroner was informed of the circumstances. At ten o’clock next morning no certificate came, and I directed further inquiry, the result of which was, that the ship had gone to sea, surgeons and all, and the owners knew nothing about it. I then directed a post mortem examination of the bodies to be made by the surgeon attached to this court, and lo and behold you, he discovered that neither from cholera nor any other disease had the children died – they died of starvation (sensation). I heard a fact this morning which really startled me, and I did not at all thank the gentleman who gave me the information. I am told there is a class of men who go and represent themselves to be surgeons, and who are not surgeons at all (sensation). I believe that chemists go with a desire of getting a free passage, and being paid besides, and represent themselves as being properly qualified to take charge of the passengers on board those ships. In a recent case, the number of passengers on board a ship might be two hundred perhaps; a great number of whom were females, and as the matter turned out, married females, many of them in an advanced state of pregnancy. A person of this class had been appointed surgeon of the ship, and he found there was a great responsibility, which might turn out very seriously to him, and he went to my informant, and said, “What shall I do under the circumstances?” “Well” said the other, “you had better do nothing.” In fact, doing nothing was best, and leaving them to the charge of the females on board. I told that gentleman that he was morally responsible for anything which may happen in the case, for it was his duty, on hearing this, to have informed the owners of the ship, so that a proper person might be appointed to take charge of these females and of the people on board. I hope that no casualty will occur; but we do not know what may happen. It is not long ago, at one of our principal hospitals – I will give you the name, the Northern Hospital – I missed, in one of my visits there, the door porter, and I said, “Where has he gone? Has he left you?” “Yes, sir,” was the reply, “he has gone out physician on board a ship” (laughter). “What!” I said, “gone as an M.D.! Do you mean to say he has taken charge of a ship?” “Yes. That was what I was informed.” The house porter had absolutely taken charge of the passengers on board a ship, and “M.D.” was his qualification. This is a state of things which most certainly ought to be at once remedied. Take the case of the female today. She dies on board the Ben Nevis also, and there is the certificate. One party signs his name “Blennerhasset,” the other signs something like “Hankey,” but both use the very vague title, “M.D.” It means really a doctor of medicine, but I could put another construction on it, which, perhaps, would be a better and more appropriate one; but I will not trust myself to do so. He then read the following certificate:

“Ship Ben Nevis. – We hereby certify that Regina Sahatta (sic), 37 years of age, died this morning at half-past seven o’clock, on board this ship, from effusion on the brain caused by excessive grief of losing a child.



You heard the medical evidence given to-day, that the woman died from an inflammation of the lungs. Just imagine this poor woman being treated for an effusion of the brain, while inflammation of the lungs was the cause of death.

A Juryman thought the remarks of the coroner would apply to American vessels chiefly: it would be found the Australian vessels were better in this respect.

The Coroner said this vessel, the Ben Nevis, was going to Australia.

A Juryman stated he had been sailing in ships out of Liverpool for eighteen years, and he never knew a proper doctor to be on board. Ask them for medicines, and they said nothing was the matter with you. He had seen from ten to fifteen bodies thrown overboard for want of proper medical attention.

The Foreman said the jury agreed entirely with the coroner, as to the want of proper inquiry as to the qualifications of surgeons on board emigrant ships.

The Cork Examiner has the following particulars of the arrival of the Ben Nevis emigrant ship, with cholera on board, at Queenstown: -

“In our last publication we were only able briefly to announce the information conveyed by a telegraphic dispatch of the arrival of this vessel in Queenstown, with cholera on board; we are now able, from the report of Dr. Scott, the medical officer in Queenstown, to supply the full particulars. It appears that this vessel sailed from Liverpool on the 29th of September with 446 German emigrants on board, and carrying a crew of 12 in number. the vessel, before leaving Liverpool, was lying in the Sandon dock, and there, on the 17th ult., cholera made its appearance, four cases having been reported. In consequence the passengers were landed, and measures were taken for the necessary cleaning and purifying operations. The passengers were then re-embarked, but on the 23rd two fresh cases again broke out, and these were removed. No additional cases having occurred up to the 26th , the vessel was cleared and allowed to proceed to sea. Soon after sailing, however, some of the emigrants began to sicken, and as many as eight on that very day. The captain, however, observes, that on the first it was conceived to be sea sickness. On the next day, four more persons were seized, and on the 28th, three. On the 29th (Friday last) she arrived in Queenstown, and on that day seven persons were taken ill. Among those taken ill on that day was Dr. Blennerhasset, the surgeon, son of Dr. Blennerhasset, who, we regret to say, died yesterday. Seven persons died on the passage between Liverpool and this port, and seven (including the surgeon) since her arrival in Queenstown. Up to the present time, nineteen cases remain under treatment, the majority of which are proceeding favorably. Immediately on the arrival of the vessel she was visited by Dr. Scott, and a telegraphic message was sent by their agents, Messrs. Scott and Co., to Captain DeCourey, who was in Cork. On that gentleman going down to Queenstown, the Admiral, Sir W. F. Carroll, placed at his disposal the hulk of her majesty’s ship Inconstant, the destination of which up to that time had remained a mystery.

[According to Pastor Jan Kilian’s death records:

Fifteen people died while in Liverpool harbor, 16 to 26 September, twelve from cholera, culminating with the death of Rosina Schatte, not Regina Sahatta, on26 Sep 1854.

Seven died while in the Irish channel, 27 to 29 September.

Thirty-one died while off Queenstown, 30 September to 23 October, 28 from cholera like symptoms.]